Best Pizza in New York

I came for a quick bite for lunch. I sat at the bar and ordered a slice of the mushroom pizza. I enjoyed the thicker crust and flavor of the sauce. The pizza shop is quaint and has a good atmosphere. The service is always quick and they are nice. I would recommend stopping there for a slice of pizza. Also, the prices are reasonable.

Scarr’s is a solid spot for a legit NY pizza experience! The back seating area makes it feel like a proper sit-down meal, and the bar’s a chill vibe—perfect for sipping a 🍺 beer and grabbing a slice. The classic NY cheese slice was good, but the Sicilian square stole the show with its crispy, flavorful crust. The Hot Boi brought some 🔥 spice with hot honey that hit just right, and the pepperoni had those perfect crispy, cupped edges. The sauce is savory, not too heavy, and the dough’s crisp, though I’d love a touch more salt. Service was fast, and the bartender was super friendly. Plenty of seating and clean restrooms make it stand out. It’s not my top NYC slice, but I’d swing by again for the vibe and that Sicilian! 🍕

One of the best pizzas you’ll ever have. The Hotboi slice is perfect and spicy, vodka pesto is super flavorful and they’ve perfected the Sicilian. Super crispy and saucy. Skip the line and grab a table in the back ahead of time.

I had Scarr’s Hotboi pizza, featuring beef pepperoni, jalapeño, and hot honey, which was truly an experience! The right thing mount of spice and the right amount of sweetness from the honey. The dough was thin and crusty. Loved it! (It’s also Yungblud’s favorite Pizza spot in NYC!)